Clay County Circuit and Superior Courts
Indiana uses circuit courts, superior courts, and certain local courts where authorized. For Clay County, the practical public trial courts are Clay Circuit Court and Clay Superior Court. The Clay Circuit and Superior Court page identifies the local court offices and officials, while the Indiana Judicial Branch lists Clay County in Judicial District 19 with Clay, Putnam, Sullivan, and Vigo counties.
The courts sit in the Clay County Courthouse at 609 East National Avenue in Brazil. The County Clerk is in Room 209, Superior Court is in Room 203, and Circuit Court is in Room 314. This room-level setup matters because a person may appear in one room for court, then request a file, certified copy, judgment entry, or marriage record from the Clerk in another room.
The local rules make the court names more than labels. They decide where traffic, ordinance, probate, juvenile, felony, misdemeanor, small-claims, protective-order, and family cases are assigned. That assignment affects which courtroom appears on a notice and which court name appears in MyCase.
The official court page is the local starting point for judge and office information.
That page anchors Clay County Circuit and Superior Courts information to the county's own court office listing.
Clay County Trial Court Table
Clay County does not have a long list of numbered district courts. The required trial-court table is therefore a local court and office table, using the actual Clay County court names, rooms, phones, and case-assignment notes from the research.
| Court / Office | Type | Address | Phone |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clay Circuit Court | Trial court; Judge Dave Thomas | 609 East National Avenue, Room 314, Brazil, IN 47834 | 812-448-9036 |
| Clay Superior Court | Trial court; Judge Robert Pell | 609 East National Avenue, Room 203, Brazil, IN 47834 | 812-448-9031 |
| Clay County Clerk | Unified court clerk; Nichole Keller | 609 East National Avenue, Room 209, Brazil, IN 47834 | 812-448-9024 |
| Traffic Division / Clerk | Traffic and ordinance payments and pleas | 609 East National Avenue, Room 209, Brazil, IN 47834 | 812-448-9032 |
| Prosecutor | Criminal charging and diversion | 609 East National Avenue, Room 326, Brazil, IN 47834 | 812-448-9028 |
| Adult Probation | Adult supervision office | 120 South Alabama Street, Brazil, IN 47834 | 812-448-9033 |
Circuit vs Superior vs Local Courts
Clay County's court comparison is not a district-court, county-court, and justice-court split. The State Court Structure Map says no official Clay city or town court record source was located, and traffic plus ordinance cases are assigned to Clay Superior Court under local rules. The useful local comparison is Circuit Court, Superior Court, and the absent lower-court channel.
| Topic | Clay Circuit Court | Clay Superior Court | City / Town Courts |
|---|---|---|---|
| Probate and estates | Assigned here, including ES, EU, EM, GU, TR, AD, and AH case types. | Not the main probate venue. | No official Clay source located. |
| Traffic and ordinance | Not the main traffic venue. | Traffic infractions and ordinance violations are assigned here. | Not documented in official county court sources. |
| Misdemeanors | Not assigned when misdemeanor is highest charge. | Assigned here when misdemeanor is the highest-level charge. | No official Clay source located. |
| Felonies | Shared under local allocation rules, with OWI/BAC exceptions. | Shared under local allocation rules. | No felony jurisdiction documented. |
| Small claims | Not the main small-claims venue. | Small claims and small-claims eviction are assigned here. | No official Clay source located. |
Clay County Case Flow
Case flow in Clay County depends on the case type. A felony may be allocated between Circuit and Superior Court under the local criminal assignment rules. A misdemeanor, traffic infraction, ordinance violation, adult protective order, or small claim is more likely to route through Superior Court. Estate, guardianship, trust, adoption, and juvenile case types route through Circuit Court. The County Clerk receives filings and maintains the official court record.
Criminal flow: Arrest or charge › Prosecutor filing › Circuit or Superior Court assignment › Initial hearing or arraignment › Pretrial events › Plea or trial › Disposition and sentencing › Clerk record and appeal if filed.
Civil and family flow: Complaint or petition › Clerk filing › Court assignment › Service › Answer or response › Motions and hearings › Judgment or decree › Post-judgment activity or appeal.
Probate flow: Estate, guardianship, trust, or adoption filing › Circuit Court assignment › Notices and hearings › Orders, inventory, claims, accounting, or reports › final report or later court order.
For document access after the case is open, the Clay County Clerk is the local copy and certification office.
Clay County Court Assignments
The current Clay local rules effective January 1, 2026 give a detailed assignment plan. Murder, Level 1 through Level 4 felonies, and older A, B, or C felony designations are allocated between Circuit and Superior Courts, except felony operating-under-the-influence and driving-above-legal-limit cases are not filed in Circuit Court. Level 5 and Level 6 felonies and older D felonies are also equally allocated, again with OWI and BAC exceptions.
Misdemeanor cases go to Clay Superior Court if misdemeanor is the highest charge. Miscellaneous criminal and criminal red flag cases are equally assigned between Circuit and Superior. Traffic infractions and ordinance violations are assigned to Superior Court. Juvenile cases, estates, guardianships, trusts, and adoptions are assigned to Circuit Court. Mortgage foreclosure, eviction, civil collection, dissolution, grandparent visitation, miscellaneous civil, court business, mental health, civil red flag, and judicial review are generally equally assigned unless a local-rule exception applies.
Note: Clay County local rules are current legal operating rules, so users should rely on their summons, notice, or Clerk confirmation for a specific case.
Clay County Courthouse
The courthouse is central to Clay County Circuit and Superior Courts because it houses the Clerk, Superior Court, Circuit Court, Prosecutor, child support office, juvenile probation, and several other county record offices. The official locations page places the Clerk's Office in Room 209 on the second floor, Superior Court in Room 203 on the second floor, and Circuit Court in Room 314 on the third floor. The Prosecutor is in Room 326, and Child Support is in Room 301.
The Clay County Courthouse National Register nomination documents the courthouse building tied to Clay County court records.
The room map is important because Clay County trial-court record access often requires moving between the courtrooms and Clerk's Office in the same building.
Clay County Court History
Clay County's present courthouse is the fifth county courthouse. The Indiana Historical Bureau marker says it was designed by John W. Gaddis of Vincennes in Classical Revival style and built from 1912 to 1914 of limestone. Interior features include a central rotunda with stained-glass skylight, marble wainscoting, granite columns, and inlaid tile floors. The skylight was restored and four tower clocks were installed in 1986.
The courthouse was listed in the National Register of Historic Places in 1999, and the historical marker was installed in 2001. For court records, the history point is continuity. Clay County court records moved from paper books, judgment dockets, and permanent historical records into modern systems, but MyCase and Odyssey do not replace the Clerk. Older records, non-linked documents, and certified copies still route through the County Clerk.
Clay County Appeals Path
Final judgments and appealable orders from Clay Circuit Court or Clay Superior Court normally go to the Court of Appeals of Indiana. The Clerk's responsibilities page says the Clerk prepares or approves Records of Proceedings for appeal to the appellate and supreme courts. The Indiana Supreme Court may accept transfer or handle matters assigned by constitution, statute, or rule.
Federal cases from Clay County are separate from local trial-court records. Clay County is in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana, Terre Haute Division, and federal appeals go to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit. PACER and federal CM/ECF are separate from Clay County Clerk records.
That split is important during a records search. A Clay County felony, divorce, small claim, probate matter, or traffic infraction belongs in the local court and Clerk system. A federal civil rights case, federal criminal case, bankruptcy matter, or federal appeal uses federal court systems instead. The court name on the notice or docket is the best clue.
The Southern District of Indiana is the federal trial-court source for federal cases arising in the district.
The federal district court source is distinct from Clay County Circuit and Superior Courts records held by the County Clerk.
The Southern District court information page explains federal court locations and district operations.
Federal court information helps separate local Clay County cases from cases filed in the federal system.
The Seventh Circuit is the federal appeals court for the Southern District of Indiana.
The Seventh Circuit image supports the appeals distinction between state trial-court appeals and federal appellate records.